The latest fad on Netflix is a series recently release tilted, "13 Reasons Why" based on the story of Hannah Baker who commits suicide and leaves audio tape recordings for all those who did things that affected her and were a reason she decided to take her life.Here is my list of at least 13 Reasons Why you NEVER need to watch this series:
- Glorifies Suicide: This is a heavily dramatized story of a suicide, in which it glorifies the person committing suicide, who in death brings justice to those that wronged her. The sad truth is that this is likely to motivate some to commit suicide through copycat ideas because of its glorification. Suicide is a terrible thing which takes the life of someone before their time. It is always sad when someone takes their life. They and those who love them suffer beyond explanation.
- Dramatized with Hollywood Style Twists: While trying to show how cruel acts can cause pain, suffering & depression to the victim, the film is filled with Hollywood twists and turns taking away from the true nature of suicide and its effects. Lets be clear this movie was made for entertainment purposes more than it was for suicide prevention.
- False Blame for Suicide: While the film presents the idea that we should not bully, judge or sexually assault others it is portrayed in such a way that also places blame & guilt on others for the individual's decision to commit suicide. We have suicide prevention programs because we can help prevent suicide by showing kindness, supporting and uplifting others. However it is never our place to blame another individual for someones decision to end their life. The message that should be shared is no matter what terrible things you experience, life can still be worth living. And never let someone else's pain continue to hold power over you by taking away the rest of your earthly experience.
- Say Something: Little if at all is shown the principle promoted by anti-suicide / anti-depression groups to say something when you see it happen. Time and time again does Clay Jensen see Hannah bullied but never does he step in and stand up to his peers to say its not okay. His character role is to "not care what others think about Hannah" and he worries that Hannah thinks he does care what others say about her. Hannah is the person that steps up time and again to tell others their judgement's, accusations and bullying is not okay. She is the hero to herself and to those around her but in the end she is the person who takes her life. It is so important that our children know when they see someone bullied not only to not participate but stand up to their peers and to tell a trusted adult.
- Mistrust in Student Counselors / Adults: This series does little to reinforce the bond between youth and the adults around them. None of the family relationships are close enough where the youth feel comfortable talking about the real problems they are facing with their parents. The counselor for the school gives bad advice to the students and makes them feel like they are the problem. He also lies during at least part of the movie to stay out of trouble. Students should be able to trust their counselors or a teacher or a parent. They should know if they are experiencing feelings of depression or facing bullying they can find help.
- Vigilante : Another issue that arises with this series is the promotion of vigilante activity. Clay Jensen a love interest that develops throughout the series begins taking matters into his own hands and bullying those who hurt Hannah Baker. He is filled with anger and wants those who treated Hannah poorly to be punished. There is some commentary on whether or not it is right but it is still shown and in essence seen as acceptable. Becoming a bully is not a solution to the problem and teaches kids the wrong way to respond to these kinds of situations which brings us into our next problem.
- Lying: Deceit is prolific throughout the series by adults in trusted positions, classmates and even one of the lead protagonists falls into a pattern of deceit often when there is no need. When Clay receives the audio tapes, he steals his friends cassette player so he can listen to them. Throughout the film he withholds information from his parents & sneaks out late at night. He also lies to Hannah's mother about how much he knew her or if he was aware she was bullied. The consistent withholding of information from parents and general lying teach demoralized values. Much of the deceit occurs in fulfillment of its Hollywood style story-line. Once we know of someone being bullied or abused we should immediately say something. We should be able to trust our parents and ideally have an open relationship with them.
- Vulgar: The film is prolific with swearing: taking the Lord's name in vain, dropping the f-bomb frequently by every main character, side characters, teachers, parents. It is dropped in each episode.And in one at least 10-15 times.
- Alcohol & Drugs: Alcohol is easily accessible and used by many of the High Schoolers. It is the norm to underage drink. And getting totally wasted. There is at least two scenes in which you know drugs are going to be used or you know have been used.
- Sexually Explicit: The film contains nudity repeatedly shows the full naked backs of men. A Girl is shown in her bra. There are graphic rapes scenes uncomfortable to watch. A masturbation scene in which nothing is shown but seemed out of place. Constant sexually denigrating actions / comments toward woman.
- Gay / Lesbian: Some scenes are brought up to address the bullying kids can receive for feeling same gender attraction. There is at least one scene in which 2 girls get drunk and then start daring each other to do things in which quickly escalates to a full make out. It is shown as shameful but the protagonist who participated also justifies it and is okay with it.
- Not for Children... or Adults: As expressed in previous reasons this movie is explicit with a rating of TV- MA according to www.healthychildren.org this means it may be inappropriate for audiences under 17. I would agree with this rating and did not feel comfortable finishing the season. Wikipedia is a great source if you are hooked to the story line and want to know how it ends.
- Better Resources: There are better resources for understanding suicide / bully prevention including:
- Cyberbully Watch on Youtube (Movie)
- Bullying Stop It (Short Film)
- American Foundation for Suicide Prevention (website)
Theses are a semi-detailed description of 13 Reasons Why you NEVER need to view this series. If you know of more appropriate or shows which better address Suicide Awareness please post! I would not recommend this film to anyone as it does not address suicide in the appropriate way and brings out more questions than it answers. While it does bring a realistic look into some social groups and verbal / physical abuse some people are faced with today we do not need to see it in such raw footage to get the message. When delivered in such a way it can desensitize young minds and leave those those living a more wholesome life a little traumatized. Those who experienced such horrors will be reminded all too well of what they went through and it will defeat the purpose of the message.We shouldn't have to watch a feel good movie having been left so yucky . . .


